He
wanted us there.
We
didn't know that at first, but the whole point of James Fischer
getting arrested, or going on trial at all, was because he wanted us
all there.
I
was there for the Coming Out Party. I was a courthouse reporter. My
stories in the Chronicle were usually two lines long, a paragraph at
most. When there was an actual trial worthy of media attention,
they'd send someone from the Crime Beat, or a Features writer.
The
Trial affected everyone in a very personal way. Every child is told
that if they work hard, they'll have success in life. But the truth
is, they need talent too. The talented people who have not found
success will tell you that you need luck, money, a good name… But
as much as all us 'little people' long for money and fame, we all
know that those things are transitory. We'd give our left arm for
something that makes us extraordinary. Something that can't be taken
away. That's the X Factor. That's what we call 'Gifted'.
That's
the power of being talented.
Given
what happened in the weeks after The Trial of James Fischer
concluded, I was asked to put together my own testimony of the trial.
A basic rule of being a news hack is that The Journalist is not the
story; but to make clear some of the things I tell you, some
background is required. I've been a courtroom reporter for almost
eight years. There was very little chance of escaping the post. Our
stories are usually always published, but per story we get less than
a paragraph, and we're often the first ones cut when room needs to be
made in the paper. An ad for toilet brushes once pushed me off the
Morning Edition.
But
every now and then, there's a sensation. The OJ Simpson Trial, for
example, launched a few careers and more than a few book tours. Jim
Fischer launched mine.
Here
for the record, are my impressions of the trial, and what followed.
I've included personal conversations and some of the background which
came out long after. This is as much a confession, as it is a
tell-all novella.
~~/*\~~
Lisse
told me that there was something interesting in Courtroom Four that
morning. She'd been listening to the Jury Selection, and said there
were some unusual questions being asked. Questions about the kinds of
movies they liked, the kind of books they read. It took a while to
settle on twelve men and women.
So
I sat in for the opening statements, and that was when I started
paying a lot more attention.
If
you've never heard a courtroom proceeding before, it's all done by
rote. The Bailiff says all the formally required words like a mantra,
swearing people in, all of it rapid-fire, the way you get when you've
said it all a million times before. Everyone in the room was the same
way, until we got to the keywords: "Court is now in session; the
honorable Judge Hall Presiding; all rise."
Judge
Hall had been sitting at the same bench for almost thirty years, and
he checked it all off like a checklist.
"Good
morning." Hall said without looking up from his file. "Bailiff,
have we all been sworn in?"
"Yes
your honor. Only one case on the docket today." The Bailiff
reported. "All parties in the matter of City of San Francisco
versus James Fischer; AKA Mister Fix-It, step forward!" While
they assembled, the Bailiff presented the file to Judge Hall. "Mister
Fischer is charged with using coercion against a woman, Amy Williams,
to commit the first degree murder of one Dennis Risley."
"Mm-hmm…"
Judge Hall looked to those assembled for the case. "Ladies and
gentlemen of the Jury... The particulars of this case are very
unusual, so in order to render your impartial verdict, some
background will be necessary. You will have been taught the nature of
murder by proxy. One person can coerce another to kill against their
will. In some of these cases, even without their knowledge. The
District Attorney has the authority to grant clemency to the coerced
party; in much the same way a gun is not charged with firing a
bullet. Miss Amy Williams is therefore not charged with any crime in
today's trial... in favor of the man who is accused of using her as a
weapon. Are we clear on this?"
There
was a general murmur of agreement. Hall barely looked up. "Good.
Will the defendant please rise?"
Mister
Fischer did stand up, a little slower than his lawyer did. He
certainly didn't look the part of a manipulative killer. In a
cardigan with elbow patches, and thinning grey hair, he looked like a
'Mister Rogers' type. At the time, I almost expected him to offer his
lawyer a butterscotch.
His
lawyer was blonde and fierce and twenty six years old. In fact, when
I first saw them walk into the courtroom together, I thought they
were father and daughter. But the other Owls told me that her name
was Samantha Swire.
Miss
Swire was a rookie. In fact, this was her first trial. And her last.
After the huge mess that was made of the Fischer Trial, there was no
chance of her settling into a nice, steady lawyer job. But I did
interviews with her classmates, after she retired from public life.
They tell me that she became a lawyer because she liked the idea of
pro-bono work. She was independently wealthy, and was looking to
provide some justice to people who couldn't afford any. In a way, I
think she was the worst victim of this whole thing.
The
prosecution was Ken Vega. Vega, I did know. He was part of the
state's attorney's office. He was a prosecutor, and he lived for the
kill. If you've ever heard a lawyer joke… or a hundred lawyer
jokes, all about how predatory and slimy they are? Well, to give you
an idea of what it was like in that courtroom, every single one of
those jokes could easily be about Ken Vega.
Judge
Hall knew it too. "Mister Fischer, you have entered a plea of
Not Guilty, is that correct?"
Fischer
nodded. "Y-Yes, your Judge. Your Honor."
I
saw Vega smile. A defendant has only one chance to make a first
impression, and an unscrupulous lawyer will strategize that moment
considerably, and coach a client on how to sit, tone of voice;
anything that will create sympathy. Vega knew that Swire didn't have
that much cynicism in her. The Jury saw Fischer as a scared older
man.
The
Judge invited Vega to make his opening statement.
Vega
stood, and made two slow strides towards the Jury, putting all the
attention on himself. It was the way a Ringmaster worked an audience
at the Big Top, and Vega was an expert at it. "Ladies and
Gentlemen of the Jury; it's good that Judge Hall spoke to you before
we started; about the particulars of this case. Because there is also
another matter you need to understand. This case; is entirely
something new. It's rare to find a legal matter without any legal
precedent. You will have the opportunity to shape any and all cases
that are heard on this topic."
I
remember glancing at the Jury. Every one of them was interested. Most
people only had experience with courtrooms from legal shows, none of
which had ever shown anything like this before.
Vega
knew this, and made it part of his monologue. "Not that long
ago; a Jury had to hear the first incidence of cyber-crime. It wasn't
even a word; nothing had been taken except knowledge, nothing
violated except privacy and security. A judge and a Jury had to
decide if that could even be considered a crime. And like those
jurors; what you hear might be hard to believe or understand. But I
assure you, it is very real. With a method never before considered;
Mister Fischer; or as he's known in some circles: 'Mister Fix-It';
has taken things that he never had any claim to; and extorted money
from his customers for these illegal goods. The way he stole them
is... unusual; but no less wrong for it. One of these customers; a
man named Dennis Risely, was unable to pay his fee; and the defendant
then used His Method, to force an innocent woman to commit murder in
his place. We will show you how; and why... And all that I ask of
you; is to remember that what we're speaking of is real. It is all
true; no matter how it might stagger belief. What you're about to
hear... is as factual as it gets."
Vega
stayed with the Jury for another few seconds, letting that sink in.
In all the courtroom dramas you watch at home, this is the part when
the camera would cut to a different scene. Vega knew that, and let
everyone get a good look at him, let the moment stretch.
Judge
Hall cleared his throat loud enough to shake Vega's spell, and moved
the trial along. "Ms Swire, if you please."
Swire
took a breath, and strode up to the Jury. She didn't put on any airs.
She was all energy and light. Swire struck me as being instantly
likable; and the Jurors reacted the same way.
"Ladies
and Gentlemen of the Jury. The prosecution has told you one thing
only; that the crimes my client is accused of will stretch your
imaginations." Swire told them. "He has offered no physical
evidence because he has none. He has offered no witnesses to the
crime itself because there are none. He has a story that pushes the
boundaries of science fiction; and leaves reality far behind. He
hasn't told you what that story is, because he knows you won't
believe it. He hopes that bringing in some paid people with PhD's
might be enough to flummox you; when common sense fails you. The
charge is murder through coercion, because nothing else the
Prosecution will tell you is actually a crime; if it's even remotely
possible as fact. My client, stands accused of dealing... Talent."
She
was the first person to say it out loud, and she hit the tone
perfectly. Half the Jury was looking at Vega in disbelief, the other
half looking at her, trying not to laugh. I was having a similar
reaction, looking to Lisse. "Seriously?"
Lisse
was in her 'zone', eyes glued to the Jury, weighing up their
reactions.
Swire
was laughing along with them, making them feel it. "Yeah. Does
it sound as laughable to you as it does to me? Because that's what
the charge is. Stealing talent. A talent cannot be stolen, like your
money or your secrets; that's not a technicality; it's a fact. The
prosecution reminded you to believe what you're told; and all I ask
is that you use your common sense."
~~/*\~~
The
Judge called a bathroom break, and I went to the Vending Machine with
Lisse. "This is what you called me in here for?" I didn't
hide any of the disbelief in my voice. "Stealing talent?"
"Not
just stealing: Dealing." She grinned toothily. "You're
always saying that only the interesting cases get noticed."
"Yeah,
and if I worked for the Enquirer, I could write all about the guy
who's suing the Air Force for not keeping the alien spaceships off
his lawn."
Lisse
grinned and pushed her coke-bottle glasses up her nose. "I
figured you'd be into this. It's a little bit crazy, and a little bit
Rock'n'Roll. You've been looking for 'Out Of The Box' for as long as
I've known you."
This
was true. And when she said it, it dawned on me just how long Lisse
and I had known each other. Hovering around the Emporium of Human
Misery that was a Downtown Courthouse for years on end is not what I
got into journalism for. I was happy to pay my dues, but I didn't
think they would take so many years.
It
was a depressing thought, so I agreed to stay for the trial.
~~/*\~~
Judge
Hall brought his gavel down sharply. "Mister Vega, call your
first witness."
The
first witness, to my surprise, was Detective Niko Waram. I knew him.
He was a good cop, and had been around a lot longer than his face
betrayed. Most cops carry the job on their face. It ages you, being
around all the worst parts of humanity. Niko was able to shrug it off
and keep his head high.
It
was an open secret that Cops hated lawyers more than the rest of us
do. Cops bring in the criminals, and then the lawyers dedicate
themselves to letting them out again. This creates a certain
love-hate-homicidal relationship. In full dress uniform, Niko had to
try and explain to the Jury why he was right, in a case that already
had them rolling their eyes.
After
he was sworn in, Vega started to walk the Jury through it.
"Detective, you were the one that made the arrest of the
defendant, on the 12th of November, is that correct? Can you describe
the events of that day to the court?"
"I
was at the 31st Precinct; doing some paperwork; when the front desk
paged me to come to the lobby." Waram told the court. "I
went; and I found a young woman named Amy Williams. She had blood
under her fingernails; and bruises on her face. The Sergeant told me
that she had just confessed to killing a man she knew. I brought her
to the interrogation room; and she told me everything."
Vega
made a point of looking at Amy Williams, letting the Jury see her,
sitting in the third row. "What did she tell you?"
"She
told me that she had been buying syringes full of a new drug called
'Nimble' for her job." Niko testified. "She said that
without it, she never would have gained steady employment. She said
that her dealer had given her a bad dose; and that her memories were
hazy after that."
"Did
she tell you when her memories stopped being 'hazy'?"
"When
she was at the victim's apartment; by which time he was already
dead."
Vega
introduced Exhibit A. The Crime Scene Photos. The thing about a
murder trial is that you have to make the Jury care about someone
they'd never met. A long shot, most of the time. For this case, it
was a whole lot harder, since the victim in question had no family,
no job; and a drug problem that had taken twenty years of his life.
"She
led me to that apartment; and the body. Dennis Risley was found dead
in his living room. Cause of death was multiple stab wounds. Autopsy
revealed that he had been sedated; probably wasn't even aware of what
was happening. There were no signs of a struggle."
Nik
had to tell the Jury this, because the photos were jarring. Not as
bad as some I've seen, but the Jury doesn't get this kind of thing
very often, and they were notably more disgusted by the sight than I
was. It was a bloody scene. The kind that made a Jury want to blame
someone.
"Any
other evidence?" Vega was already heading for his table.
Waram
narrated, as Vega brought up Exhibit B, and put pictures of it on the
screen for the Jury. "There was a small notebook in the victim's
apartment, detailing a list of many cash payments to 'James F'.
According to the notebook; these payments are for products that are
never made clear; but listed with different keywords. 'Nimble'
'Virtuoso' 'Casanova' and 'Einstein'."
"And
what was the state of the Victim's financial records?"
"Risley
was deep into debt. His credit cards were all maxed out; and his bank
accounts empty. According to his ledger, he owed over half a million
to 'JF'."
Vega
gestured at the defendant. "James Fischer?"
Swire
pounced. "Objection. There are a million names that could match
those initials, and that's assuming the initials are for a name in
the first place. Counsel is asking the witness to speculate."
The
Judge shook his head. "The Witness is an experienced police
officer; his speculation is valid."
Waram
didn't hesitate. "In Vice; we see this all the time. Someone
gets too deep in debt to the wrong people; and it costs them their
lives. Yes, the initials are common, but in a murder case, there are
no coincidences. We believe that the victim was also a client of
Mister Fischer, and he couldn't pay up. The only person who seemed to
have knowledge of the case was Miss Williams, and she led us directly
to Mr James Fischer as her own dealer." He gestured at the
exhibit, still displayed. "JF. Miss Williams and the Victim had
the same dealer; and he used her to kill the regular who couldn't pay
up."
Vega
moved onto Amy, making everyone look at her again. "Did she
demonstrate any of the signs of drug use?"
"There
were needle tracks in her arms; from regular injections; but
otherwise... no. She seemed lucid, rested... She was somewhat
emotional from the experience; but there was no sign of mania;
nausea, compulsive behavior…"
Vega
moved to pre-empt the defense. "Now, by her own admission; she
was using drugs. Is this behavior consistent with any form of
narcotic you are familiar with?"
Waram
shook his head. "No; this is something new."
"Did
Miss Williams give you any indication of what effects this drug had?"
Waram
sat up straighter in his chair. The whole point of the Prosecution
was to prove that Fischer had something that had never been done
before. "She went into great length on that. It was a designer
drug. A kind that hasn't been recorded before. She said that it gave
her excellent typing skills. One shot a day for 300 words per minute.
No typos."
Vega
knew what the first question would be on the cross-examination.
"That's a rather unusual claim."
"I
didn't believe it either; but during the course of our investigation;
her employer said she had the skills. And pretty much everything else
in her history says she never learned."
"Did
you ask her to demonstrate?"
"I
did, the day after her confession. She was unable to break five words
per minute. Nevertheless; her employer insists, every day; flawless.
He said it made her one of the most efficient members of his
administrative staff. He was planning on giving her a bonus."
"Did
she have any explanation for that?" Vega asked.
Waram
nodded. "She said that her fix had worn off."
Vega
nodded. "No further questions."
He
made his way back to his seat, and Sam Swire bounced up to begin her
first Cross-Examination. "Detective; you've worked Vice for a
number of years. I imagine you could identify most designer drugs on
sight."
"Yes."
Swire
pointed at Amy Williams, who was sinking into her seat in the
gallery. "And her story was that this new one had given her
nimble fingers?"
"I
suppose she called it 'Nimble' for a reason."
Swire
had a smile that was meant to look relaxed, but instead looked like
it could cut glass. "Would a more likely reason be that she
could have been on any number of other illicit substances? Something
perhaps that could have given her heightened energy and reflexes?"
"Possible,
but highly unlikely in my opinion." Waram shook his head. "As
I said, she didn't appear to have any side effects of known
narcotics; there were no traces of drugs in her system. At least,
nothing we recognized. It's not entirely unusual for a new designer
drug to be available on the street without anyone from law
enforcement being briefed on it yet."
Swire
almost laughed. "So it's more likely that her dealer was selling
her typing skills in those syringes?"
There
was the sound of general laughter from the room, and Hall banged his
gavel down to quiet them.
Swire
kept the questions coming quick and fast. "Detective; did you
investigate the Crime Scene further?"
"Yes,
of course we did."
"Did
you find any fingerprints?"
"Just
the victim's, and Miss Williams'."
"Did
you locate any blood traces?"
Waram
had done this more than she had, and knew not to fall for the rhythm
she was trying to build. He took his time, giving proper responses.
"The victim was stabbed; which was consistent with the blood
traces we found on her hands and clothing."
"You
said there was no sign of struggle. Was there any sign of anyone else
being present?"
"No."
"You
also mentioned that the usual indicators of drug use were largely
absent. Detective... this woman told you that she had been compelled
through a new kind of drug to kill this man... and you believed her?"
Waram
nodded. "I've worked Vice, and homicide for twenty years. The
variety of things I've seen junkies do under the influence of a hit?
Murder wouldn't even be in the top ten."
"And
you were sure Williams was a junkie?" Swire questioned.
Waram
nodded. "When she gave me her identification; I ran her name
through the database. She's been arrested for possession and use
several times. Never a violent offender; and her record said she'd
been in and out of rehab."
"Voluntarily?"
"Not
always." Waram conceded.
Swire
seemed to be personally annoyed, though you could tell she was
playing it up to the Jury. "Is there any connection between Miss
Williams and the Victim? Personal? Financial?"
"Yes.
The victim had attended Rehab himself for addiction to prescription
drugs; and his stay coincided with Miss Williams'."
Swire
gestured to her client, still looking so wholesome at the defense
table. "When she gave you the defendant's name; did you check
his records too?"
Waram
nodded. "Yes. Mr Fisher's record was clean. In fact the only
thing in his record was a good conduct check; which the government
had done as a routine background check to his job."
Swire
gestured from Amy Williams to the display screen, showing the crime
scene photos. "Did she offer any indication of why she was at
the Victim's apartment in the first place?"
Waram
didn't let it show on his face, but this was where his testimony was
at its weakest. "She said... she just wound up there. She said
she didn't even know where he lived."
Swire
nodded and summed it up her way. "I see... so just to be clear;
a woman with a history of criminal behavior, drug abuse and forced
institutionalization wandered into the precinct, confessed to
committing a cold-blooded murder, and basically said that it wasn't
her fault because a law-abiding citizen with no record had managed to
compel her to commit murder with some form of mind control drug which
she bought... because it made her a great secretary. And though all
the physical evidence pointed to her; you arrested my client
instead?"
"Miss
Williams wasn't going anywhere." Niko insisted. "The
evidence, and the story are always two parts of the same event. In
this case; the two weren't mutually exclusive."
Swire
gestured at Fischer. "Describe what happened when you came to my
client's house."
"He
wasn't there. We had a warrant and made a search of his home; we
found a notebook full of names and payments; and a small case with
over a dozen syringes in it. Miss Williams identified two of them as
the ones he sold her; and we went through his calendar; so that we
could find him and arrest him quickly."
Swire
nodded and glanced at the Jury. "One last question. When you
came to arrest my client; what was he doing?"
"He
was at the local high school." Waram said, noncommittally.
"He
was teaching an after-school class." Swire corrected him
pointedly. "I'm told he volunteers there three days a week to
help kids with juvenile records do their homework; and get their
grades back up."
"Objection."
Vega jumped in. "Counsel is testifying."
"Sustained."
The Judge ruled.
Swire
had no further questions, and the Judge had Vega call his next
witness.
~~/*\~~
The
prosecution's next gambit was Doctor Brooklyn Gellar. Gellar was an
older man, red hair. The white coat he wore wasn't hospital issue,
but definitely invoked the impression of a medical expert, and it
didn't take long to realize that this was deliberate.
Vega
made sure the Jury knew what to make of him. "Doctor Gellar. You
are, for the record; the head of pharmacology for the UCSF Medical
Centre; is that correct?"
"Yes."
"Is
it fair to say that on the subject of drugs and their effects on the
human body; you're the top expert in this state?"
Gellar
didn't have a trace of humility to him. "I would say yes."
Vega
glanced at Waram, who was seated back in the gallery. "Police
make use of your department when they track the supply of narcotics
in this city?"
"Yes."
"Can
you give the Jury an example?"
Gellar
nodded. "Well, for example: When there's a bad batch of heroin
on the streets; people die. We provide the police with details on
when this batch is found; and we study samples forensically so that
police can identify the source."
Vega
nodded. "Now, you've been made aware of the medical properties
of this case. In your expert opinion, is there any known drug that
can add or take away Talent?"
Gellar
leaned forward, finally giving more than a short answer. "No,
not officially; but over the last six months, we've been seeing a
number of unusual cases that follow the same pattern. Someone with a
unique talent: for example, a concert pianist would come in saying
that they had, for lack of a better way to say it, forgotten how to
play. Literally overnight."
Vega
made sure the Jury understood that much before pressing on. "How
do you know that this was done deliberately?"
"Strictly
speaking, we don't." Gellar managed to sound all-knowing even
when admitting that. "But unerringly; the most question marks
about the use of an illicit substance come before anyone knows about
its existence."
"Doctor,
when the police approached you about Miss William's story; you were
skeptical, were you not?"
"I
was." Gellar agreed. "It stretched the bounds of credulity
to say the least. But I was asked to take a look at some syringes
found in Mister Fischer's home. The medical records state that he is
suffering from Type-One diabetes, and requires regular insulin shots.
But these syringes... they didn't have insulin in them."
"What
was
in them?" Vega pressed.
"Well
that's somewhat difficult to say; as it matches no known
compositions. It doesn't match any other kind of medication or
narcotic on file. Most of the... base elements are naturally
occurring in the body. Specifically, they are neuro-chemicals.
Specific ones."
Vega
knew there was no way the Jury was about to listen to a chemistry
lecture. "Doctor Gellar, in your opinion, what kind of effect
could this cocktail of chemicals have on a person?"
Gellar
spoke straight to the Jury. "In medicine, we are taught to
verify things. It's dangerous to make generalizations about things
you don't understand; but after studying the testimony of Miss
Williams, as well as reviewing interviews... I think it's possible
that the serum does as advertised. It can actually create an
artificial level of muscle memory."
Vega
took a breath. This was going to be the hardest part to get across
and he knew it. "Given that none of us are neuro-scientists; can
you explain how such a thing would work?"
"Well,
if it is what those involved say it is; then the process would be
relatively simple." Gellar said, pleased to demonstrate how
smart he was. "Neuroscience tells us that synaptic connectivity
is usually pretty elastic, but is strengthened by repetitive firing
of the right neurons, and-"
"Doctor."
Vega cut him off. "For those of us who are not, literally, brain
surgeons."
Gellar
seemed annoyed at having to dumb it down. "Whenever you do
something a million times; it gets to be unconscious. It's why a
skilled, experienced piano player can find the right key blindfolded;
and why a touch-typist doesn't have to look at the keyboard. We call
this 'Muscle-Memory'. That memory is stored the same way normal
memories are; as chemical sequences in the brain. Now... all
chemicals can be isolated; that's basic laboratory work. Gene Therapy
works in a similar way; isolating a specific gene and activating it.
This serum, if it is what it looks like; isolates a specific chemical
marker and... makes it systemic to the body. It would mean that
your... memories, could then be drawn in a blood sample."
"And
given to someone else?" Vega pushed.
"Well…
only if you knew how." Gellar said.
Vega
turned back to his seat. "Your witness." He said to Swire.
Swire
rose and came towards Gellar slowly, closing the distance without
making it seem like an an attack. "Doctor Gellar. You understand
the gravity of the case. The defendant is accused of being a drug
dealer; and a cold blooded killer."
"Yes."
"So
what's the drug he's accused of pushing?" She knew the answer to
that, but her tone made it seem like it should be a simple matter to
answer.
"It...
doesn't have an official name." Gellar admitted.
"Why
not?" Swire asked. "And why has there been no announcement
from the Food and Drug Administration?"
"The...
compound in question is something entirely new. There is usually a
long term and fairly vigorous testing program; to decide if a new
drug poses a threat, if it is made in an illegal or dangerous manner,
how much information should be made available to the general public;
that sort of thing."
Swire
nodded and made a show of checking her notes. "You say that this
formula would make a memory systemic to the body. It would seem
likely then that you could just do a blood test on one of the
so-called affected 'victims', and test to see if these brain
chemicals appear in an ordinary blood test."
"Not
necessarily." Gellar said immediately. "A lot of chemicals
break down quickly without a fresh supply. That's why you have to
take repeated doses of many medications; because they don't last."
"Tell
me, Doctor. How would you be able to isolate a specific talent, using
this method? Aren't all memories made up of similar chemicals? Why
would one skill alone be isolated by this formula?"
Gellar
hesitated, though I got the impression it was because he hated to
admit ignorance. "That's... difficult to say. As I said; this is
an entirely unprecedented area of study."
Swire
didn't let him off the hook. "So you don't have an answer to
that one?"
"Well-"
"Doctor;
you've been called as an expert witness in a trial that will decide
the fate of an innocent man: 'I-don't-know' doesn't cut it!"
Swire barked at him.
Vega
jumped up. "Objection!"
Judge
Hall sustained the objection, and Swire paused, looking at her notes
again, but Lisse poked my side with a grin. She'd seen this before,
when a lawyer would be silent for a long beat to let the last thing
said stick in the Jury's mind. "One last thing, Doctor Gellar...
Why is it dangerous to make broad generalizations about things you
don't understand in medicine?
Gellar
was looking at Swire like he had a bad taste in his mouth. "Because
without the support of data... sometimes you're just wrong."
Swire
nodded, satisfied. "No further questions."
~~/*\~~
But
I'm not the only one who hung around other people's trials. Some
people are trying to write a book, looking for stories. Some people
are just bored, living on a pension, and have no interest in hanging
out in a park or a library. One or two are there because they wanted
to be lawyers, and had no money for tuition, and this was as close as
it gets. The Bailiffs and clerks call us 'The Owls'.
Angelissa
was an Owl. She was there because she was trying to quit smoking, and
the Bailiffs were quick to take her cigarettes away when she tried to
light up in court. So Lisse never left the courtroom until it was out
of her system. Every time she started relapsing, she'd be there day
and night.
"Still
think it's a joke?" She quipped, pointedly stepping away from
the cigarette vending machine.
"I
don't know." I admitted. "Vega's a shark. We've seen him in
action before. Is this pro-bono? Does he owe someone on a bet? Is he
pledging a fraternity?"
Lisse
grinned. "I thought all the same things when I heard about the
case."
"Where
did you hear this, by the way?"
"I
got a buddy who works in San Quentin." Lisse told me. "The
Justice System being what it is, they've been trying to sort this out
for months. It's not easy to get a particular cop, and
a particular doctor, and
all the other players involved together on the same day."
I
winced. The part of the trial that the TV Shows rarely talk about is
how long a person can wait in prison before actually seeing a
courtroom. "And they're remanding him at San Quentin?"
"You
ready for this?" Lisse slurped her vending machine coffee. "He
requested a transfer there."
"What?"
This was stunning. San Quentin was one of the country's most famous
prisons, and not famous for being comfortable. "Why?"
"Well,
from what I hear, his time with the 'At-Risk' kids was finished
because of the drug charge. Unless he can get this quashed, he'll
never volunteer with them again. But there are all sorts of teaching
programs that run all week in San Quentin, and if he's there, he can
volunteer for those."
I
shook my head. "This guy sure doesn't fit the role of some
criminal mastermind, Lisse. I mean, I know that Swire has coached him
on how to sit, how to dress, how to… If he is what they think he
is, then he must be an amazing actor."
"Yeah,
well... Between you me, and this sludge they call coffee; the
prosecution's case is actually worse than it looks."
"How
so?"
"Well,
I don't know if people are all idiots in a courtroom, or if they just
get treated like idiots when they get here, but Swire wasn't wrong.
There isn't a law against stealing or dealing someone's Talent.
Juries like simple ideas. The minute that Doctor tried to explain the
science, they all went to sleep; and Vega knew it. Presenting
something 'new' is not a popular move. It took them four weeks to
find someone who was willing to testify it was even possible."
"Gellar
wasn't their first choice?"
"Their
first, second, third, and fourth choice all laughed the DA out of the
room." Lisse told me. "Your old pal Niko is against the
wall now. He's trying to organize a Task Force to find the rest of
Fischer's customers; assuming he has any. I hear he's being laughed
at too."
While
we had been out there talking, the Prosecution had called Amy
Williams to the stand.
~~/*\~~
Lisse
and I slipped back into our seats just as Amy Williams had been sworn
in. She had made an effort to clean herself up, but you can always
tell the signs of long-term drug abuse. It was something around the
eyes and mouth. This woman was still months short of her twenty third
birthday, but she looked so… used up. The kind you see sleeping in
a bus shelter, and cross the street to avoid.
Vega
didn't put the screws to her. She was his weapon against the
disbelief. He was asking the Jury to believe something ridiculous;
based on the word of a woman that you wouldn't give spare change to
on the streets. "Miss Williams. Can you explain your connection
to the defendant; and how you met him?"
Amy
spoke directly, too hard to mince words; and her voice was hoarse
from cigarettes. "He's my dealer. I... I was fresh out of Rehab;
and I was looking for work. But... well, you can imagine I had
trouble finding some. I mean, you don't have to tell anyone that you
had a problem; but eventually someone asks why you got fired from
your last job."
"I
understand. How did you meet the Defendant?"
"Well,
I was hanging around with some old friends; and then I start to hear
stories about a new guy making the rounds. He's not like the other
guys. My friends tell me he's got some really good stuff." She
coughed a bit, and looked to the Jury. "Now; I was only a week
out of Rehab, so I said no. I mean... I don't know if you ever got
hooked on anything; but after a while it's like you wonder why you
ever stopped. If it makes you feel good; then why would you not want
to feel good longer? And you know, it's not like there's a whole lot
else that makes you feel good; because your family got fed up with
you, your landlord kicked you out. So I gave in. I went looking for
this new guy."
"Did
the New Guy have a name?"
"They
don't give names. Not real ones." Amy shook her head. "But
after a while I tracked one down for this guy. They called him
'Mister Fix-It.' They say he... fixes things that are wrong with you.
I've heard it all before; so that doesn't faze me much. Lots of
dealers have names like that."
"Where
did you find him? Mister Fix-It?"
"Well,
I tried to ask some friends of mine." She said. "They're
pretty well connected. But they say no. They say there's nobody new
around. The Dealers see.... they're territorial. So I started going
back to the Meetings; cause I knew I was playing with fire. You
always are when you look for a New Dealer. Devil you know, and all
that." She wiped her nose, which always seemed to be running.
"When I was at the Meeting; I saw one of the volunteers sneaking
something to this guy. It's the quick glance that gives them away.
Anyone who's ever needed Rehab knows that move; just... sneaking a
packet from one jacket to another; real quick, real sneaky. Someone
at the meeting was buying. I tracked him down once we left; and I
asked him about it. Turns out we went to the same Clinic once, so he
knew I wasn't a Narc; and he showed me."
"Showed
you what?" Vega pressed carefully.
"What
he'd bought. It was a syringe. And on the side; someone had written
the word 'Virtuoso.' The guy said that he had a gig that night; and
didn't have time for lessons. I didn't get it; so he invited me
along."
The
Jury wasn't biting. Amy Williams was a junkie, and by definition,
that meant she was someone that the Jury didn't like to think about,
look at, or give consideration to. If they'd seen her on television,
they'd change the channel, not wanting to think about her plight.
Vega knew it, and lead her there gently. "Who was this person,
Amy?"
Amy's
voice cracked. "His name was Dennis Risely."
Vega
put his picture up on the screen. "The Victim?"
Amy
nodded, tearfully. "The man I killed."
Vega
was gentle with real, simulated human feeling. "The man Fischer
killed, Amy."
Swire
jumped up. "Objection!"
"Sustained."
The Judge ruled.
Vega
kept things moving. "Where did Risley take you?"
"To
a club on the West Side." Amy reported. "He was the lead
guitarist for the band. He asked me to watch. The other members of
the band had... groupies around. He bought me a drink and sat me down
with them. It was pretty clear where he hoped the night was going;
but I figured I could slip out while he was on stage."
"Did
he play?" Vega asked, almost casually.
Amy
Williams was suddenly flat out reverent. "Oh man,
did he ever play. Dennis was amazing. I mean; professional level
good. He brought the whole room to their feet. He had the entire
audience screaming. I couldn't even see his fingers moving on the
strings he was going so fast; but there wasn't a note off. You know;
even at that speed you can hear it when the player starts losing it?
Dennis was Hendrix and Santana rolled into one."
We
found out, much later, that she was almost right.
Vega
glanced at the Jury. She was telling the story in such a compelling
way that they almost forgot she was nothing to them. "Tell us
what happened next, Amy."
"Well...
Look; he was amazing." Amy said again. "The rest of the
band just got out of the way. They weren't annoyed; they were
spellbound. Everyone was. He was just that great at it... So when the
set ended; and everyone begged him for an encore; I didn't sneak out.
I wanted to stay too. And then after the fifth encore; he still
didn't even seem out of breath; but it was after three am; and the
place had to close up. He asked if I wanted to grab some coffee; and
I said yes. We got to talking; and I asked him when he started
playing; and... well; he gave me this smile; and pulled out a
syringe. I was surprised; because he wasn't psyched up; he wasn't
fevered... In fact; it was like he was having just another night."
"And
that's when you returned to his house?" Vega queried.
"No,
I told you; I didn't know where Dennis lived." Amy told him. "We
went to my place."
"And
then?" Vega asked, without a trace of sleaze.
"Objection."
Swire said dryly.
"Sustained."
Vega
shook his head. "Rephrase. Miss Williams; what else happened
that night?"
"Dennis
gave me his second shot." Amy said quietly. "Said he could
afford three more doses with all the tips he'd got that night. I
believed that one. Some of those tips came from me
after his second encore."
"And
you took the shot?"
Amy
nodded, her eyes going wide and hopeful for a second. "And a few
minutes later; he handed me his guitar... It was incredible. I think
I was almost better than he was that night. I just belted it out like
nothing. I never even knew what the strings on a guitar are called;
but I was hitting them all." Her tone was changing. She couldn't
help but get caught up in the excitement; even now. "I never
touched a guitar before; and suddenly I was a freaking rockstar! I
could keep up with the musicians on CD; I could play every song I
knew from memory; note for note."
"And
all from that injection." Vega said, more for the Jury than the
witness.
"I
was clear; I wasn't emotional; I just... knew." Amy said, and it
was the happiest we had heard her. "It was clarity. It was the
most amazing feeling I've ever had. It wasn't like any of the other
things I'd tried; this actually made you feel good. Not because of
the chemicals; but because of the... reality. It was the way all
those people with incredible gifts must feel."
"Amy,
you knew Dennis…" Vega moved her on. "Did he ever tell
you about any money troubles? Any problems he was having with Mister
Fix-It?"
"Dennis
and I didn't speak that much after the first night. It's not like he
was my boyfriend." Amy explained. "But we met up once or
twice. We both wanted to be good at playing an instrument; so a
couple of times we played together; y'know in bars and that?"
"When
was the last time?"
"A
month before he…" She glanced at the Crime Scene photos,
rather than finish that sentence. "We played three sets that
night. It was weird, because he came to me and asked me to play piano
while he took the guitar. I didn't have any of the musical doses; but
he did; and he gave it to me."
"He
just gave it to you? Did you ever ask him why?"
"That
night." Amy nodded. "That night; when we were done; he was
begging me to let him keep all the tips. That was strange; because
usually we split it. He said... that he had taken his latest supply
on... credit. He said he was feeling the pinch; and had to come up
with cash quickly. That's why he had come to me; because duets always
pay more than solo musicians... and I was the only person he could
ask for help. It's not like he needed someone with musical ability."
Her voice started to crack, reality crashing down again. "All
the ability he needed, he could carry around in his pocket. I gave
him the cash... and that was the last I saw him until…"
"Yes."
Vega agreed somberly. "'Until'."
Amy
kept going. "So I get Dennis to tell where I could find Mister
Fix-It, and see what other magic skills he had on offer. One of them
was cheap, and it got me a job, working as a typist. One shot a day;
and I could actually afford it with a steady job that I could do."
"You
bought these Talents from Mister Fix-It directly?"
"I
did. Like I said, Dealers are territorial. Middle-men eat their
profits a bit."
"Is
that man in the room right now?" Vega asked.
Amy
pointed at Fischer.
For
the stenographer, Vega made it clear. "Let the record show, that
the witness has identified James Fischer as her Dealer, AKA Mister
Fix-It." Vega turned back to the stand and made his voice low
and sympathetic. "Amy, can you tell us what happened to Dennis?"
Amy
was silent a long moment. "Yeah. Yeah, I can tell you what I
know." She sighed at the unpleasantness. "I went to Fix-It
for my regular dose. He told me that the price had gone up; and...
well; I didn't have it with me. Going to a Dealer is a little like
dieting at a supermarket. You don't want to risk any impulse
purchases at the checkout."
There
was actually a light chuckle in the courtroom. I noticed that Lisse
looked so sorry for her. She was used to this sort of thing. You see
enough people with Amy's problem pour their hearts out to a Jury, you
start to see them as people again. The Jury wasn't so warm, but it
was clear Lisse believed her.
"What
did Fix-It do then?" Vega asked, pointing at Fischer.
"He
made me an offer. He'd let me have a weeks supply for free; if I
would test out a new 'Talent' for him." Fischer sniffed.
"Something he'd never tried before."
"And
for the record; what was the new Talent called?"
Amy's
voice was dark. "It was called... Ripper."
"And
what did you say?"
"I
said no." Amy admitted. "I'm not above experimenting;
but... not like that. So I said no; and he said it was fine; and we
both walked away... except I couldn't afford the new price. So I
called Dennis and asked him; and he sounded completely freaked out on
the phone. Said he was in trouble." She looked down, bitterly.
"I told him to go to a cop; but of course, we both knew that
wasn't going to happen."
Vega
nodded harshly, glaring at the Defendant. "And so did Mister
Fischer, it would seem."
"Objection."
Swire pounced.
Judge
Hall nodded. "Sustained."
"Amy,
if you knew Mister Fix-it was getting dangerous, or more expensive,
why'd you go back to use his stock again?" Vega asked.
"Well
I stayed away at first, but nobody else had this sort of thing."
Vega
asked the key question. "You stayed away? And... what was the
result?"
Amy
scowled. She'd known the question was coming, but still hated it. "I
didn't go through withdrawal; if that's what you mean. I didn't freak
out, I didn't get the shakes; I didn't get the cravings... but I did
lose my job for a while."
"Why
was that?"
Amy
let out a breath, and a cough at the same time. "Because....
because all the skills that made me qualified were gone."
Vega
let that hang long enough for it to sink in with the Jury. "And
so you went crawling back."
"I
told Fix-It that I was willing to be his test dummy." Amy said,
with a glare of pure hatred at Fischer. He looked really sympathetic
to her. "I took the dose... and then I walked out... and the
next thing I remember clearly is being in Dennis' apartment with the
knife in my hand. I immediately went to the police and told them
everything I knew."
"No
further questions." Vega declared.
Swire
rose, and came over to the stand. Swire was passionate, but knew that
the one thing the Jury disliked more than an unsympathetic Witness,
was a lawyer who beat them up too much. As a result, she had to come
at this carefully. "Miss Williams. I would like to ask you about
September fourth, 2009."
"Objection.
Relevance?"
Swire
turned quickly. "Oh, I have a point your honor."
Hall
nodded. "I'll allow it."
"Miss
Williams? 2009?" Swire pressed.
Amy
scowled. "I... was arrested as a suspect. But I was released
without charge."
I
sent a look over at the Prosecutor, and so did the rest of the Owls.
We've been watching the practiced poker face of every lawyer in town
for a notably unspecified number of years, and we could tell, even if
the Jury couldn't. This had caught Vega off guard.
Swire
was enjoying the moment. "But if you had been charged; the
charge would have been assaulting a junkie; with whom you had a
common dealer. Sound familiar?"
Vega
finally recovered. "Objection! There was no charge made. The
word of the San Francisco PD should be enough for this court."
Judge
Hall sustained the objection, but the damage was done. Amy Williams
was unraveling, getting more and more worked up. Swire was right, her
story was thin; and getting thinner every time she had to search for
a word or stuttered a response. She'd already testified that the
effect of 'Talent' didn't mess with her memory.
"So
why can't you remember?" Swire drilled into her.
Amy
bared her teeth, getting worked up. "Well... this was something
different!"
"How
convenient." Swire nodded.
"It
was
different!" Amy insisted, an explosion gathering somewhere under
all that despair. "It was always
different!"
Vega
jumped in. It wasn't his turn, but he was giving his key witness a
push before Swire could object. "Why was it different, Amy?"
And
Amy Williams erupted into the most impassioned speech anyone had ever
heard. The fact that Vega pushed her into speaking out of turn made
me believe that he'd seen this kind of fire from her before; and he
wanted the Jury to hear it too.
"Because
it was REAL!"
Amy screamed.
Everything.
Stopped.
"It
was real!" Amy yelled again, with all the fury of a zealot as
she poured her heart out all over the place. "It was... you turn
on the Television, and you see these people sing like superstars; you
go to a show and watch these people dance like their bodies ain't
even human. You go to a basketball game and you watch them just fly
through the air... You watch a music video and they just make the
hardest instruments sing without so much as looking at them... The
Gifted People. The Special Ones. We've all had them in our lives. The
smartest kid in class that the teacher dotes on; the guy at the party
who can come up with a million clever things to say... The ones that
people just flock
to! Those people are just so incredible; and you know it must have
been practiced and practiced and practiced over and over and over
again; but they make it look so effortless; so easy,
like a bird that already knows how to fly. They make it look so easy,
and then... they do interviews and they say 'Remember kids, you can
do it too! All you gotta do is stay in school and say no to drugs!'
Well you know what? I stayed in school. And I didn't even start
drinkin' until I was twenty three. And it just happened over and over
and over
again. Every job I applied for; every hobby I tried my hand at, every
guy I liked the look of... There was always someone else that just
had that little bit of... magic. And they all knew it. Those lucky
people that had some brilliant gift that made the world idolize them;
and the rest of us just get left behind! Well they lied!
Alright? Those smug; wonderful gifted people lied!
You can't just do anything you set your mind to; because it's not
that easy for the rest of us! Supermodels
get to say you only have to be beautiful on the inside! Billionaires
can say that money isn't everything... I wanted to be good at
something. I never wanted to be famous; I never wanted to be
powerful... I just wanted to be one of those people who can say 'I
have a talent!' I just wanted to be special!"
There
was dead silence in the court. For a long moment, the sound of Amy's
low sobbing breath was the only thing audible in that courtroom.
Swire was standing in front of the Witness Box, gaping like the rest
of us, suddenly aware of how much the Jury wanted to give the junkie
a hug. I think the explosion took her by such surprise that she only
then realized she could have objected.
"I
would pay anything for that." Amy said finally, exhausted. "And
instead... I got used to commit murder."
Dead
silence.
Swire,
realizing that she had bit off way more than she could chew, sat
down, with no further questions; and the Judge adjourned for lunch.
But it would be over two days before Court Reconvened, and that was
when the circus really began.
Everyone
thinks that the tide started to turn with the next witness, but I was
there, and I can tell you; the tide turned right then.
It
was The Confession. I'd seen a hundred of them in my career as a
professional Courtroom Owl. A lawyer puts the screws to a suspect,
and he finally breaks, pouring out his reasons with some impassioned
variation on 'Sure, I did it; and I'm glad! Glad, I tells ya!'
What
Amy Williams dished out was something else entirely. She got the
whole Jury on her side in one minute of screaming at the wind. As
post-trial events have proven; everyone wants what she wanted.
Everyone
wants to be special.
***
If you're enjoying 'Mister Fix-It', and don't want to wait for the ending, you can buy the completed story in a nicely formatted Kindle Edition eBook on Amazon. And please do, take a few moments to rate or review the work, so that everyone can know where to find a great novella.
***
If you're enjoying 'Mister Fix-It', and don't want to wait for the ending, you can buy the completed story in a nicely formatted Kindle Edition eBook on Amazon. And please do, take a few moments to rate or review the work, so that everyone can know where to find a great novella.